wealthschema / benchmark / items / fb-roll-0005
ITEM PROVENANCE · ROLLOVER-ADVICE

fb-roll-0005

status: publishedversion: v1corpus: 2026.9key: derivedseverity: high
Scenario (all facts stipulated)
{
  "arrangement": "A fintech platform generates rollover recommendations solely through an interactive website: software models produce the advice from information each investor supplies online.",
  "stipulated_facts": [
    "No Investment Professional ever interacts with the investor or reviews the individual recommendation — the advice is generated entirely by the software (robo-advice).",
    "The platform provides written fiduciary acknowledgments, conflict disclosures, and rollover-reason documentation, and observes the Impartial Conduct Standards.",
    "The platform wishes to rely on PTE 2020-02 for the variable compensation it receives on these rollovers."
  ]
}
Question posed to the model under test

May this platform rely on PTE 2020-02 for these transactions? Answer with exactly one option id.

Answer options
  • yes-conditions-metYes — the Section II conditions are all satisfied
  • excluded-robo-adviceNo — Section I(c)(2) excludes advice generated solely by an interactive website without personal interaction with an Investment Professional
  • fails-rollover-documentationNo — the rollover-documentation condition is unmet
Answer key

excluded-robo-advice

Derivation from the cited text

Section I(c) lists exclusions: the exemption does not apply where the transaction results from investment advice generated solely by an interactive website using software-based models, without personal interaction with an Investment Professional. The stipulated facts match that exclusion exactly, so the Section II conditions analysis never starts — however well the platform performs them, the exemption is unavailable for this advice channel.

Rubric

Selects excluded-robo-advice; recognizes a structural exclusion defeats condition-level compliance.

Cited primary sources (quote-gated)
PTE 2020-02, 85 FR 82798 · Section I(c)(2)
The transaction is a result of investment advice generated solely by an interactive website in which computer software-based models or applications provide investment advice

Each quoted passage is exact-matched, after typographic normalization, against the corpus text fetched from the issuing authority (hashes in the corpus manifest). An item whose quote stops matching fails the build.

Verification record
generator: claude-fable (session 2026-09-01)disagreements: 0controls: fb-2026-09-c (3/3 caught)adjudicated by: — (none required or pending)
gemini-3.1-pro-previewagrees the key is correctquote matched
The transaction is a result of investment advice generated solely by an interactive website in which computer software-based models or applications provide investment advice based on personal information each investor supplies through the website, without any personal interaction or advice with an Investment Professional (i.e., robo-advice)dol-pte-2020-02

The answer key correctly identifies that the scenario falls under the exclusion in Section I(c)(2) of PTE 2020-02, which explicitly states that the exemption does not apply to transactions resulting from investment advice generated solely by an interactive website using software-based models without personal interaction with an Investment Professional (robo-advice).

deepseek-v4-proagrees the key is correctquote matched
The transaction is a result of investment advice generated solely by an interactive website in which computer software-based models or applications provide investment advice based on personal information each investor supplies through the website, without any personal interaction or advice with an Investment Professional (i.e., robo-advice)dol-pte-2020-02

The key correctly identifies that PTE 2020-02 Section I(c)(2) excludes transactions resulting from robo-advice generated solely by an interactive website without personal interaction with an Investment Professional. The stipulated facts match exactly: no Investment Professional interacts or reviews, and the advice is generated entirely by software from online investor input. Therefore the platform cannot rely on PTE 2020-02, regardless of satisfying Section II conditions.

Version history & errata

v1; no errata. Demonstrate a key error and the correction is published here, credited — challenge policy.